Reindeer Peanut Butter Ritz Holiday Cookies

I’ve seen Christmas stuff out for months and I couldn’t resist anymore.  I grabbed a few ingredients and made these super duper easy and adorably cute holiday cookies.

Super easy and fun reindeer peanut butter Ritz holiday cookies  | Thirty Handmade Days

They are so sweet but really take a small amount of work.  That’s a win in my book! They’d be perfect for a cookie exchange party and to make with your kids.

Step by step to reindeer peanut butter Ritz holiday cookies | Thirty Handmade Days

I made Ritz Peanut Butter Cookies for a cookie exchange party a long time ago and people are shocked when they find out what they are made of.
The ingredients for the cookie part are simple- Ritz crackers (or similar), peanut butter, chocolate to melt (lots of different ways to do this).   To make the reindeer all you need is edible oogly eyes, pretzels and cinnamon candies.

Super easy and fun reindeer peanut butter Ritz holiday cookies

Reindeer Peanut Butter Ritz Holiday Cookies
  • 100 Ritz crackers (any round buttery salted crackers will do)
  • 1-1/2 c. creamy peanut butter
  • 1 package (24 oz) chocolate almond bark or meltable chocolate
  • 1 package cinnamon candies
  • 50 small twist pretzels
  • 100 edible candy eyes
  1. Roll out wax paper on a cookie sheet.
  2. Spread peanut butter on the flat side of one cracker. Then sandwich one on top.
  3. Repeat with all crackers, set aside.
  4. Melt almond bark in the microwave according to directions (double boiler can be used as well)
  5. Place cookies in chocolate and swirl around until covered, remove and place on the wax paper.
  6. Add 2 eyes, 1 cinnamon candy and pretzel on top to create the reindeer.
  7. Let stand on wax paper for about ½ hour to 1 hour to harden.
  8. You can also put in the fridge to set up quicker.
  9. If you aren't serving these immediately you can store them in air tight container or freeze them.
  10. Use wax paper in between the layers of cookies.

You can purchase all of the supplies at most grocery stores and I’ve found the edible eyes at Walmart, Target and Joann’s.  Or my friend Leigh Anne has a post on how to make your own edible eyes. But in case you’d like to order online, you can grab them here: (affiliate links included)

Super easy and fun reindeer peanut butter Ritz holiday cookies

I placed the pretzel at the top of each cookie right after I set them on the wax paper.  Josh suggested cutting the bottom half off so that they would be more stable and still look like antlers.  You can do whatever you think looks best.   The jury is still out on who won that debate in our home.

Super easy and fun reindeer peanut butter Ritz holiday cookies in container

I didn’t stop there, I created a cute little tag after I found some adorable containers at Target.   I’ll be sharing how I packaged everything up and the printable soon.

Reindeer peanut butter Ritz holiday cookies with cute tags  | Thirty Handmade Days

Looking for some other holiday treats?  Check these out:

Easy Christmas Gifts - Root Deer Float Kit with printables from www.thirtyhandmadedays.comRoot Deer Float Kit

Adorable reindeer hot cocoa gift idea for Christmas!

Reindeer Hot Cocoa 

Delicious Christmas Truffle Cupcakes from www.thirtyhandmadedays.comChristmas Truffle Cupcakes

Hi- I'm Mique (as in Mickey). I started 30days as an idea file a few years ago. After three years and hundreds of ideas, I now realize that I'll never check them all off my list. When I'm not creating, I love spending time with family and friends and long drives, especially if they end at the beach.

Latest posts by Mique (see all)